Metal Casting: High-Pressure Die Casting, Permanent Mold Casting and Sand Casting

Aluminium casting defects – types, causes and prevention

Gas and shrinkage porosity, misruns, cold shuts, hot tears and oxide inclusions – an overview of aluminium casting defects with their causes, detection methods and ways to prevent them.

Published: 8 min readPoznań Foundry Team

Table of contents (13)
  1. 01What is a casting defect?
  2. 02Classification of casting defects
  3. 03Gas porosity
  4. 04Shrinkage cavities and shrinkage porosity
  5. 05Misruns and cold shuts
  6. 06Hot tears
  7. 07Oxide and non-metallic inclusions
  8. 08Dimensional and shape defects
  9. 09How are defects in aluminium castings detected?
  10. 10How to specify defect criteria in an order?
  11. 11Frequently asked questions
  12. 12Aluminium castings without surprises – start with a drawing review
  13. 13Sources and standards

Aluminium casting defects are deviations from the requirements of the drawing and the technical delivery conditions that reduce the strength, pressure tightness or appearance of a part. The most common are gas and shrinkage porosity, misruns, cold shuts, hot tears and oxide inclusions. We classify them according to recognised systems, explain their causes and show how to prevent them at the design, mould and melting stages.

In brief

  • A casting defect is any deviation from the drawing or delivery requirements, but not every discontinuity disqualifies a casting.
  • The most common defect in aluminium is porosity, which has two sources: hydrogen dissolved in the molten metal and shrinkage during solidification.
  • Molten aluminium is covered with an oxide film, and turbulent flow in the gating system carries it into the casting as inclusions and crack initiators.
  • Most defects are prevented long before quality control: through part design, the gating system, mould temperature and metal refining.
  • Acceptance criteria for defects must be written into the order, because the material standard EN 1706 does not specify them.

What is a casting defect?

A casting defect is any deviation in dimensions, mass, shape, appearance, material continuity, structure or properties from the requirements of the drawing, a standard or the technical delivery conditions. The same discontinuity may be acceptable in an unmachined, unloaded wall and unacceptable on a sealing surface. That is why a defect is always assessed according to the function of the area in which it occurs.

Acceptable, repairable and rejectable defects

In practice castings are divided into three groups: free of defects or with acceptable defects, with repairable defects, and with defects that lead to rejection. Flash and small irregularities are removed by grinding, and through-porosity in pressure-tight castings is often sealed by impregnation. Internal defects in loaded areas usually lead to rejection, because weld repair changes the material structure and requires the customer’s approval. The rules for such repairs are described in our article on welding aluminium castings.

Classification of casting defects

The International Atlas of Casting Defects divides defects into seven groups marked with the letters A to G. The classification is common to ferrous and non-ferrous alloys, and aluminium castings most often show defects from groups B, C, E and G.

GroupType of defectExamples in aluminium castings
Ametallic projectionsflash, fins at the parting line, metal projections from a cracked mould
Bcavitiesgas porosity, blisters, shrinkage cavities and shrinkage porosity
Cdiscontinuitieshot and cold cracks, cold shuts
Ddefective surfaceexcessive roughness, scabs, flow marks
Eincomplete castingmisruns, castings left incomplete by metal run-out
Fincorrect dimensions or shapecore shift, mould shift, distortion
Ginclusions and structural anomaliesoxides, dross, sand, hard intermetallic inclusions

In Poland defect terminology is organised by standard PN-85/H-83105, which divides defects into four groups designated W-100 to W-400: shape defects, surface defects, discontinuities and internal defects. In purchase orders, however, it matters more to specify precisely which defects are acceptable and in what size.

Gas porosity

Gas porosity consists of spherical pores with smooth walls, dispersed throughout the casting or concentrated just below its surface. In aluminium its main source is hydrogen, which the molten metal picks up from moisture in the atmosphere, the charge and the tools. At the melting point liquid aluminium dissolves about 0.69 cm³ of hydrogen per 100 g of metal and solid aluminium only about 0.04 cm³, so during solidification the excess gas is released and forms pores.

Causes of gas porosity

  • A damp or contaminated charge, fluxes and tools.
  • Overheating the metal and holding it in the furnace for too long.
  • No refining or ineffective degassing before pouring.
  • Gases from moulding sands, cores and coatings, and air trapped by turbulent pouring.

How to prevent gas porosity?

The basis is refining the molten metal, most often by purging with inert gas through a rotating impeller, and checking metal quality before pouring. The process is described in detail in our article on degassing and refining aluminium.

Reduced pressure test

A quick assessment of the hydrogen content of the melt is provided by the reduced pressure test. It compares the density of a sample solidified under vacuum with that of a sample solidified in air: the greater the difference, the more hydrogen the metal contains. How to calculate density and porosity is explained in our article on the density of aluminium.

Shrinkage cavities and porosity

Aluminium alloys shrink in volume as they solidify. If a solidifying region is not fed with liquid metal, a shrinkage cavity with irregular walls or dispersed shrinkage porosity forms. Such defects most often appear in heavy sections, at wall junctions and under feeders that are too small.

How to tell shrinkage porosity from gas porosity?

Gas pores are spherical and have smooth, often shiny walls. Shrinkage porosity is irregular in shape, with visible dendrite tips, and is located in the areas that solidify last. The distinction matters, because each of these defects requires a different remedy.

Preventing shrinkage defects

  • A design with walls of as uniform a thickness as possible and smooth transitions.
  • Directional solidification towards the feeders, supported by chills.
  • Correctly sized feeders and a correct connection to the casting.
  • Control of mould temperature, which in a permanent mould determines the order of solidification.

The role of feeders and metal delivery is discussed in our article on the gating system.

Misruns and cold shuts

A misrun is a casting in which the metal has not filled the whole mould cavity, most often in thin walls far from the gate. A cold shut forms when two metal streams meet but do not fuse completely, leaving a visible line or gap on the surface.

Causes of misruns and cold shuts

  • Metal or mould temperature that is too low.
  • A flow path that is too long and walls that are too thin for the casting method.
  • Pouring too slowly or interruptions in the metal stream.
  • Insufficient venting of the mould cavity.

The minimum wall thicknesses for each process are listed in our article on aluminium casting methods.

Hot tears

A hot tear forms at the end of solidification, when the mould or a core resists the contraction of the casting while the material still has very little strength. Such cracks are usually short, ragged and oxidised, and appear where stresses concentrate, for example at sharp corners.

Alloys with a wide freezing range, for example those containing copper or magnesium, are more susceptible to hot tearing than eutectic alloys of the AlSi12 type. Hot tears are prevented by rounding corners, using collapsible cores, keeping the right mould temperature and removing the casting from the permanent mould early.

Oxide and non-metallic inclusions

Molten aluminium instantly becomes covered with a thin film of aluminium oxide. When the metal stream folds over, the film is drawn inside as double, folded layers. Such inclusions reduce strength and elongation, initiate pores and cracks, and appear on machined surfaces as dark spots or streaks.

Sources of inclusions in castings

  • Turbulent flow in the pouring basin and at the ingates.
  • A contaminated charge, oxide skin and dross skimmed into the ladle.
  • Sand grains washed out of the mould or a core.
  • Fragments of die coatings and hard inclusions caused by excess iron.

They are counteracted by calm pouring, ceramic filters, a properly designed gating system and careful cleaning of the metal before casting.

Dimensional and shape defects

This group includes core shift, mould shift, distortion and dimensions outside tolerance. They usually originate from tooling, core fixing, shrinkage and stresses that arise during cooling. Permissible deviations of the raw casting are specified by a tolerance grade, as described in our article on casting tolerances according to ISO 8062-3.

How are defects in aluminium castings detected?

The choice of inspection method depends on the type of defect and the customer’s requirements. Surface defects are assessed visually and by penetrant testing, internal defects by radiography, computed tomography or on metallographic sections.

MethodWhat it detectsWhen to use it
Visual inspectionsurface defects, misruns, cold shuts and cracks visible to the naked eyefor every batch
Dimensional measurementcore shift, distortion and dimensional deviationson first castings and according to the inspection plan
Penetrant testingcracks and pores open to the surfaceon critical surfaces and after machining
Radiography and tomographyporosity, shrinkage cavities and inclusions inside the wallsin safety-relevant castings and loaded areas
Leak testingleaks and through-porosityin pump bodies, valves and sealed housings
Metallographic examinationstructure, type of porosity and oxide filmswhen analysing the cause of a defect

An overview of non-destructive methods can be found in our article on non-destructive testing of castings. Requirements for parts operating under pressure are described in our text on leak tightness of aluminum castings.

How to specify defect criteria in an order?

Standard EN 1706 specifies the chemical composition and mechanical properties of the alloys, but it does not say how many pores, and of what size, are acceptable in a casting. These requirements must be agreed with the foundry before production starts.

  1. Mark the critical zones on the drawing, for example sealing surfaces, threads and the most heavily loaded areas.
  2. Specify the inspection method and the scope of testing for each zone.
  3. State the acceptance criterion, for example the largest permissible pore diameter or a level according to reference radiographs.
  4. Decide which repairs are acceptable and whether they require your approval.
  5. Approve the first castings before series production starts.

A checklist that helps when accepting samples is provided in the article check these things before approving a casting.

Frequently asked questions

What are the most common defects in aluminium castings?

The most common are gas and shrinkage porosity, oxide inclusions, misruns and cold shuts, and in alloys with a wide freezing range also hot tears. Their share depends on the casting method and the part design.

Can a porous aluminium casting be repaired?

Through-porosity in castings that must be pressure-tight is often sealed by vacuum impregnation with resin. Impregnation does not improve strength, however, so it is no substitute for eliminating the cause of the defect in the casting process.

Are casting defects visible before machining?

Only some of them. Porosity and inclusions hidden below the surface are often revealed only by machining. That is why it is worth defining which surfaces are critical and choosing allowances so as not to remove the soundest layer of the casting, just below its surface.

Which casting method produces the fewest defects?

Each method has its typical defects. High-pressure die casting favours gas porosity, while gravity casting favours shrinkage defects in heavy sections. The result depends on matching the method to the part geometry, on the gating system and on process discipline.

Aluminium castings without surprises – start with a drawing review

Many defects can be foreseen before the mould is made. Send us a drawing or a 3D model, and our process engineer will point out areas at risk of porosity and cracking and propose design changes, a gating system and the scope of inspection. We cast in sand moulds, permanent moulds and high-pressure dies, and we monitor die temperature with a thermal imaging camera. Send your project with a request for a quotation.

We work within ISO 9001:2015 and ISO 14001:2015 management systems, as presented on the page of our aluminum foundry in Poznań.

Sources and standards

  • International Atlas of Casting Defects, American Foundry Society – classification of defects in groups A to G.
  • PN-85/H-83105 – Castings. Classification and terminology of defects.
  • J. Campbell, Complete Casting Handbook, 2nd ed., Butterworth-Heinemann, 2015.
  • EN 1706 – Aluminium and aluminium alloys. Castings. Chemical composition and mechanical properties.
  • EN 1371-1 and EN 12681 – penetrant and radiographic testing of castings.

Author: Poznań Foundry team

Poznań Foundry is a brand of Adjatech Metalworking Sp. z o.o., a family-owned non-ferrous foundry in Poznań. The Brukwicki family has been in foundry pattern making since 1950. We cast aluminum alloys in permanent molds, in sand molds and by high-pressure die casting; we machine the castings on CNC machines and powder coat them. We operate under ISO 9001 and ISO 14001 management systems (TÜV Rheinland Polska certificates).

About usCertificatesCompany details

Blog

Read also

More guides on castings, machining and working with a foundry.

All articles

Contact

Have a question about castings?

Send a 2D drawing as a PDF or a 3D model in STEP format, specify the material and quantity, and we will advise on the right process and prepare a quote.

Feel free to contact us by e-mail or phone

Office · Mon–Fri 8:30 a.m.–4:30 p.m.

Poznań Foundry

+48 61 662 43 37odlewnia@adjatech.pl

or visit us in person – you are welcome!

ul. Gnieźnieńska 26
Janikowo near Poznań
62-006 Kobylnica

Office open Mon–Fri 8:30 a.m.–4:30 p.m.

Get directions (Google Maps, new window)

Company details and directions: Contact page